the university writing center
"because writers need readers"

University Writing Center Home|Scheduler|Online/Phone|Writing Resources|Faculty Resources|Graduate Resources|UWC Staff| HIM

 

Logical Fallacies

The misuse of logical appeal in an argument often results in a logical fallacy: faulty reasoning that breaks down the credibility of a claim.

Becoming familiar with the different kinds of logical fallacies can help you avoid this pitfall in your own arguments, and help you recognize when others are arguing from a flawed premise.

Some of the more common fallacies are listed below, with examples...

Faulty Cause and Effect: lack of connection between two sequential events

  • Because I watched Friends last night, I passed my math test.
  • We voted Democrats into office, and then the economy went downhill.

Red Herring (Ignoring the Question): when a rebuttal doesn't address the question

  • Q: Did the President have an affair? A: "He's very busy at the moment with the Middle East Peace talks, and has no time for silly accusations."

Stacking the Deck (Slanting): leaving out one side of an argument completely

  • There should be no "moment of silence" in schools: it discriminates against certain religions, causes unnecessary controversy, takes away from study time, and mixes church and state.

Begging the Question: when the claim is included in the evidence so nothing is proved

  • Since I'm not lying, I must be telling the truth.
  • We know that God exists, because the Bible is the word of God.
  • Roger Drudge's book on politics is the best; it says so inside.

False Authority: when someone who is not an expert gives testimony

  • As an English teacher, I must say that Coke is better than Pepsi.
  • I'm not a doctor, but I play one on TV. Excedrin is the best headache medicine.

Hasty Generalization: when a claim states or implies that things are all one way

  • Women are bad drivers.
  • Gun owners refuse to consider new laws that would make our streets safer.

False Analogy: comparing two things that are not similar enough to compare

  • Bill Clinton is the Jesus Christ of the 20th century.

Either/Or (False Dilemma): when only two options are given when many choices exist

  • Either you're for the Republican plan, or you're socialist and un-American.

Ad Hominem Fallacy: an attack on the person rather than the argument

  • Don't listen to Rush Limbaugh; he's a big fat idiot.
  • James supports the new tax system; what do you expect from a rich kid?

Complex Question: when two different points are linked together in one statement

  • Do you support freedom and the right to bear arms?
  • Has George W. Bush stopped using illegal drugs? (This assumes that he has used them in the past...)

Prejudicial Language: loaded or overly-emphasized word choice

  • Right-wing fanatics and NRA storm-troopers will fight to keep guns firing.
  • Any reasonable person can see through the cloud of lies coming from the Democrats.

Wrong Direction: the cause and effect relationship is reversed

  • Cancer causes smoking.
  • More sex education has led to an increase in teen pregnancy.

Complex Cause: A complex event is shown as having only one cause

  • We lost the game because Wilson missed the last shot.

Straw Man: attacking an opponent's weaker argument rather than his strongest

  • Many who are for abortion like its convenience. But this is a human life we're talking about, and people need to be concerned with more than convenience.

Equivocation: using the same word with two different meanings

  • The sign said "Fine for Parking Here," so since it was fine, I parked there.
  • Liberal politicians favor a liberal lifestyle of free love and drugs.
  • God helps those who help themselves, so I'm gonna help myself to more of this tuna casserole.

Placing Blame Elsewhere: avoiding the question by attacking something else

  • You criticize Chinese human rights violations, but what about the homeless in American slums?