Students
Don't Know How to Document Properly: Students may be unfamiliar
with the appropriate documentation requirements for their field. Brief
in-class sessions about citation style can get students on the right
track.
The UWC
has several handouts
that deal with paraphrasing, quoting, and crediting outside sources
for MLA, APA, and other styles; our in-house reference shelf also has
documentation manuals for all major styles.
Lack
of Awareness of Writing Expectations: Students may plagiarize
because they are confused by what constitutes ownership when dealing
with ideas...which may be understandable, because what may be considered
plagiarism in one situation may not be a problem in another.
For instance,
plagiarism is usually defined as presenting another's ideas as one's
own, but teamwork often combines individual contributions without specific
acknowledgement of each group member.
Different
genres and disciplines have different expectations for documentation.
For example, researchers may rely on the work of grad assistants who
are not acknowledged in the final published work. Problems occur when
students over-generalize between field-specific expectations. For example...
Marco,
a student in an educational psychology class, must write a short review
of literature about guided discovery learning in K-12 math instruction.
He recalls a "review" essay assignment from a past composition
class, for which he wrote a response to a text but was not required
to document sources. In writing the literature review, he follows
the same model: he discusses the major research concerning his topic
but does not provide specific references.
In this
case Marco has confused the expectations of two different fields and
assignments.
Another
example (from Klooster and Bloem's The Writer's Community,
pg. 152):
A
legal studies student is assigned to write a research paper about
the legality of local rave clubs. He's about to go to the library
to look for background information when his roommate says, "I
wrote an essay on that same topic last year, and I have all my research
notes. You can just use those instead of wasting time getting all
those articles yourself." The student reads the notes and writes
his paper based upon this information.
If the
student were an intern working for a newspaper, this kind of "borrowing"
might be acceptable. In a classroom,
however, this would be considered plagiarism. Although the writer above
has written the essay himself, part of the expectation in a standard
research paper assignment is that the writer will engage in legitimate
research about the topic, and so construct meaning in an authentic way.
The audience expects that the writer has maintained integrity in locating,
reading, and considering the research material himself, all in an effort
to present insight in an honest and knowledgeable way.
Making
expectations explicit helps avoid such situations. Make writers fully
aware of what qualifies as research, how they should use sources, and
any requirements for acknowledging credit.
Poor
Planning: As much as we'd like to hope that students will
make researching, drafting, and revising a priority, the reality is
that some will not. Confronted with a looming deadline, students may
plagiarize out of sheer despair. By assigning due dates for particular
sections, instructors can head off the tendency to plagiarize through
desperation (see Structuring
the Assignment).
The
Student Has Nothing To Say: Intimidated by expert sources
and unsure of how to enter into an academic discussion, some students
have a tendency to develop a "what-can-I-possibly-contribute"
attitude. Students may drift towards using the terminology, phrasings,
and opinions of others as a measure of safety, feeling they have no
authority or voice of their own.
To prevent
this, instructors can help develop a critical confidence and voice in
students by modeling effective ways of interacting with texts. For example,
short response essays to reading assignments can help students grapple
with ideas, as can class discussions about how an article, image, film,
or similar text succeeds (or doesn't succeed) in making its point.
You can
also help students participate in the conversations of their field through
activities such as mini-debates, short class presentations, and issue
forums. These exercises ask students to discuss topics and defend stances
as experts. As students get more practice with the expectations of communication
in their discipline, they gain the confidence to make specific contributions
of their own.
Student
Choice: Ideally, we want to prevent plagiarism before it
happens by removing the conditions that create it. Even so, a few students
may plagiarize simply because they don't care, or because they believe
they can get away with it. Essay-checking sites such as turnitin.com
can discourage this behavior.