Theodicy defined
Principles used in Leibnizian Theodicy
Principle of Sufficient Reason (PSR)
Principle of Perfection (POP)
Principle of Plenitude (POPL)
The Mind of God
Possible Universes
Potential histories of all possible universes
God knows all the potential histories
God does only what is most rational, which is
what is most good (PSR, POP).
Which world does God
choose to create (actualize)?
Which world exists? THIS WORLD
1. God KNOWS all there is to know about this world = Determinism
2. When this world was only potential, God knew all that WOULD happen
in it
3. Does this mean there is no individual free will?
4. Does this mean there is no moral responsibility?
In this world's existence as a possible world, this world contained beings
who acted freely.
We are morally free, but metaphysically necessitated.
How can Leibniz justify his answers to 3 and 4?
Critical Points
So what does all this have to do with the problem of evil, or an
attempt to solve it?
Some Commentary on Theodicy from the work of Richard Swinburne:
Passive Evil - physical,
mental, state
Moral Evil - human
God should create people incapable of moral evil
What about free will?
God should make people who can do evil but with no bad results
What about moral responsibility?
God should limit pain and suffering.
God does.
How do we account for the existence of non-moral (passive) evils?
Perhaps God should have created a world with ONLY moral evil in
it.
A universe with evil in it is better than one without it - Swinburne's claim