What was Socrates' primary critique of Euthyphro's claim that piety is whatever is "pleasing to the gods"?  (This is not the same as the claim that piety is "whatever ALL the gods love.")

A short paragraph should be sufficient.

Your answer should have included a brief discussion of the notion that since the Greeks believed in a number of gods (polytheism) and those gods are said to have disagreed on important matters, it might be the case that what one god believes is pious is held to be impious by another god.  In a case like that, as Socrates points out, some particular action, belief, etc., could be both pious and impious at the same time, resulting in a logical absurdity.  Another way to put it is to say that if God(1) claims that X is pious and God(2) claims that X is impious, then X is both pious and impious, which is impossible.

If you missed this quiz on the 19th and you missed class (and the quiz) for a good, legitimate and verifiable reason, you may make it up.  Otherwise, this can be your dropped quiz grade.